Milestone 4 - Peer Review (Team)

\[ \begin{align}\begin{aligned}\newcommand\blank{~\underline{\hspace{1.2cm}}~}\\% Bold symbols (vectors) \newcommand\bs[1]{\mathbf{#1}}\\% Differential \newcommand\dd[2][]{\mathrm{d}^{#1}{#2}} % use as \dd, \dd{x}, or \dd[2]{x}\\% Poor man's siunitx \newcommand\unit[1]{\mathrm{#1}} \newcommand\num[1]{#1} \newcommand\qty[2]{#1~\unit{#2}}\\\newcommand\per{/} \newcommand\squared{{}^2} \newcommand\cubed{{}^3} % % Scale \newcommand\milli{\unit{m}} \newcommand\centi{\unit{c}} \newcommand\kilo{\unit{k}} \newcommand\mega{\unit{M}} % % Percent \newcommand\percent{\unit{{\kern-4mu}\%}} % % Angle \newcommand\radian{\unit{rad}} \newcommand\degree{\unit{{\kern-4mu}^\circ}} % % Time \newcommand\second{\unit{s}} \newcommand\s{\second} \newcommand\minute{\unit{min}} \newcommand\hour{\unit{h}} % % Distance \newcommand\meter{\unit{m}} \newcommand\m{\meter} \newcommand\inch{\unit{in}} \newcommand\foot{\unit{ft}} % % Force \newcommand\newton{\unit{N}} \newcommand\kip{\unit{kip}} % kilopound in "freedom" units - edit made by Sri % % Mass \newcommand\gram{\unit{g}} \newcommand\g{\gram} \newcommand\kilogram{\unit{kg}} \newcommand\kg{\kilogram} \newcommand\grain{\unit{grain}} \newcommand\ounce{\unit{oz}} % % Temperature \newcommand\kelvin{\unit{K}} \newcommand\K{\kelvin} \newcommand\celsius{\unit{{}^\circ C}} \newcommand\C{\celsius} \newcommand\fahrenheit{\unit{{}^\circ F}} \newcommand\F{\fahrenheit} % % Area \newcommand\sqft{\unit{sq\,\foot}} % square foot % % Volume \newcommand\liter{\unit{L}} \newcommand\gallon{\unit{gal}} % % Frequency \newcommand\hertz{\unit{Hz}} \newcommand\rpm{\unit{rpm}} % % Voltage \newcommand\volt{\unit{V}} \newcommand\V{\volt} \newcommand\millivolt{\milli\volt} \newcommand\mV{\milli\volt} \newcommand\kilovolt{\kilo\volt} \newcommand\kV{\kilo\volt} % % Current \newcommand\ampere{\unit{A}} \newcommand\A{\ampere} \newcommand\milliampereA{\milli\ampere} \newcommand\mA{\milli\ampere} \newcommand\kiloampereA{\kilo\ampere} \newcommand\kA{\kilo\ampere} % % Resistance \newcommand\ohm{\Omega} \newcommand\milliohm{\milli\ohm} \newcommand\kiloohm{\kilo\ohm} % correct SI spelling \newcommand\kilohm{\kilo\ohm} % "American" spelling used in siunitx \newcommand\megaohm{\mega\ohm} % correct SI spelling \newcommand\megohm{\mega\ohm} % "American" spelling used in siunitx % % Capacitance \newcommand\farad{\unit{F}} \newcommand\F{\farad} \newcommand\microfarad{\micro\farad} \newcommand\muF{\micro\farad} % % Inductance \newcommand\henry{\unit{H}} \newcommand\H{\henry} \newcommand\millihenry{\milli\henry} \newcommand\mH{\milli\henry} % % Power \newcommand\watt{\unit{W}} \newcommand\W{\watt} \newcommand\milliwatt{\milli\watt} \newcommand\mW{\milli\watt} \newcommand\kilowatt{\kilo\watt} \newcommand\kW{\kilo\watt} % % Energy \newcommand\joule{\unit{J}} \newcommand\J{\joule} % % Composite units % % Torque \newcommand\ozin{\unit{\ounce}\,\unit{in}} \newcommand\newtonmeter{\unit{\newton\,\meter}} % % Pressure \newcommand\psf{\unit{psf}} % pounds per square foot \newcommand\pcf{\unit{pcf}} % pounds per cubic foot \newcommand\pascal{\unit{Pa}} \newcommand\Pa{\pascal} \newcommand\ksi{\unit{ksi}} % kilopound per square inch % NOTE: do NOT define \bar -- it is the built-in LaTeX accent used by \bar{x}, % \bar{y} (sample means). Redefining it made those render as the word "bar". \newcommand\barunit{\unit{bar}} \end{aligned}\end{align} \]

Nov 16, 2026 | 406 words | 4 min read

19.5. Milestone 4 - Peer Review (Team)#

At a Glance

What you will do: Exchange your in-progress controller and report with another team. Give that team structured engineering feedback, and act on the feedback you receive.

What you will submit: A completed peer-review form for the team you reviewed. You will receive one from that team in return.

In engineering, work is reviewed before it is released. In Milestone 4, your team pairs with another team, and each team reviews the other team’s work. Both teams can use the feedback to improve before the final deliverable. A good review is specific, based on evidence, and constructive. It points out problems that the other team may not see in their own work.

19.5.1. How It Works#

  1. Your instructor pairs your team with another team and sets the length of the peer review. You will see the other team’s current controller behavior (their analysis plots and acceptance-test results) and their draft report sections.

  2. Each team completes the review form below for the other team.

  3. Read the feedback from your reviewers. In your Iteration #2 report section (TP4), record what you plan to change and what you chose not to change. For anything you will not change, give your reasoning in the report.

19.5.2. The Review Form#

Download the review form M4_Peer_Review_Form.docx and fill it in. When you finish, export it as a PDF with the file name: M4_Peer_Review_Form_Team_#.pdf.

On the form, write the team number and the names of the team members for both your team and the team you are reviewing.

19.5.3. Submission#

  • Upload the completed review form as a PDF for the team you reviewed to 19.4 Milestone 4 - Peer Review (Team) on Gradescope. Submit one form per team.

  • Be sure to submit before the deadline listed on the Course Schedule.

  • After submitting to Gradescope, share the peer review form with the team who you reviewed.

In your own Iteration #2 report section, cite the feedback you received and describe how you acted on it.

Learning Objectives

TM03:

Support Team Interactions - Demonstrate collaboration by offering help, asking questions, and actively engaging with teammates to support shared learning and mutual respect.

EB03:

Data-Supported Justification - Justify decisions or comparisons using explicit reference to data.

EB06:

Reasoned Decision Explanation - Clearly articulate reasoning when evaluating alternatives or making decisions.

PA02:

Identify Limitations in Process - Identify limitations, challenges, or inefficiencies in the problem-solving or design approach.

PA03:

Plan for Process Improvement - Identify concrete behaviors or strategies to improve future problem-solving or design efforts.

PC05:

Meeting Assignment Expectations - Fully complete all parts of each assignment according to provided instructions.