Nov 16, 2026 | 714 words | 7 min read
16.4. Milestone 1 - Client Needs Analysis (Individual)#
At a Glance
What you will do: Read the client’s memo and technical annex closely. Extract the stakeholders, needs, constraints, and success criteria that later design decisions depend on.
What you will submit: A requirements extraction from the brief and a synthesis paragraph.
16.4.1. Problem Scoping#
Problem scoping is the process of defining the boundaries, requirements, and objectives of a project. It begins with the documents the client provides, which state the client’s needs, operational constraints, and definition of success.
Most projects begin with a document, such as an RFP, a memo, or a statement of work. The engineering team extracts the requirements from that document. The team then confirms its reading with the client and resolves the points the document does not specify.
In this assignment you do the extraction. The in-class client-needs discussion covers the confirmation. Bring any unanswered questions to that discussion.
16.4.2. What to Read#
This assignment requires two documents.
The Mission Brief has two parts. The Memorandum states what Dr. Okafor requires. The Technical Annex specifies the numbers, hardware, and limits.
The Engineering Design Process page shows where this assignment fits in the project and what comes after it.
16.4.3. Extract the Requirements#
Work through the brief and record your answers in Gradescope (see submission instructions below). Each answer must cite its location in the brief (i.e., section name, paragraph). Use the client’s exact figures, and do not round them. A summary of the brief does not meet the requirements of this assignment.
Stakeholders and direct users. Identify at least six stakeholders and direct users of the control system. For each one, write one line on why they care whether GHU-2 succeeds.
Client needs. Quote at least eight statements in the Memorandum that constrain the design. Put each statement in quotation marks and follow it with a one-line paraphrase of what it requires of the design. A need is anything the client states the system must do, must not do, or will be judged on.
Measurable success criteria. Name all dimensions the acceptance test scores, the quantity behind each, and the mission length each is measured over. Where the brief gives no number for a passing result, propose your own.
Hard constraints. Every design must operate within physical and safety limits it cannot exceed. List 10 such limits, two in each of the following five categories: Crew safety, Crop survival, Hardware physical limits, Energy and mass, Environment and sensor design. For each limit, state the constraint and briefly explain why the design cannot violate it.
Unknowns. List five or more questions you would ask Dr. Okafor directly. These are gaps in the specification, or statements that need confirmation before the design commits to them. Bring these questions to the in-class client-needs discussion.
16.4.4. Synthesis#
Write a short synthesis of about 250 to 300 words. The synthesis answers two questions: what does the client need, and how will the team recognize success? Write it so that a teammate who has not read the brief can gather an understanding of the job from this paragraph alone.
The second individual assignment for Milestone 1 (Problem Formulation) builds on this synthesis. So does the Problem Scoping section of your team’s Design Project Technical Report.
A Note on AI Use
Do the reading yourself. An AI summary of the memo skips the close reading this assignment requires, and it introduces errors in the exact numbers, ranges, and thresholds the controller is graded against. The AI Usage Policy lists the uses of AI tools that this project permits.
16.4.5. Submission#
Recommendation
We recommend that you first write your answers in a Word document, then copy-paste your answers and synthesis to Gradescope. Saving a local copy to your computer will help you keep a record of your work.
Complete this assignment in Gradescope under 16.4 Milestone 1 - Client Needs Analysis (Individual).
Submit before the deadline listed on the Course Schedule.
Learning Objectives
- PS01:
Stakeholder-Based Problem Definition - Explain the problem based on synthesis of client, user, and stakeholder needs.
- PS03:
Constraints and Criteria - Define key criteria and constraints that address client and user needs.
- IL01:
Asking Questions to Guide Research - Identify gaps in knowledge and pose clear, specific questions that guide research and information gathering.
- IL04:
In-Text Citations - Include appropriate in-text citations to indicate the source of information, data, or ideas.
- PC01:
Written Communication Standards - Use professional tone, clear sentence structure, and correct spelling and grammar in all written work.
- SQ01:
Technical Accuracy - Use accurate scientific, mathematical, and technical concepts, units, and data.