Nov 16, 2026 | 715 words | 7 min read
18. Milestone 3: Design, Test and Iterate#
At a Glance
What you will do: Learn standard control strategies and design the GHU-2 controller on paper, with a flowchart and a decision matrix. Then write a first draft, run it in the controller simulation, and revise it until your crop survives.
What you will submit: One individual Gradescope activity, one team Design Memo, your first-draft controller, and your Technical Report checkpoint (TP3).
GHU-1 failed because of flaws in its control-system design. Its components were not the cause. The GHU-1 controller used simple on/off logic, did not cross-check its sensors, and had no safeguard against a controller failure. In this milestone, teams develop a reliable control strategy for GHU-2 that avoids these flaws.
Your team will study the control strategies that engineers use and propose more than one candidate design. You will compare the candidates and record the chosen design in a flowchart detailed enough to write code from. You will then write a first draft of the controller, run it in the simulation, and revise it until the crop survives. This first draft is Iteration #1. You optimize the working controller in Milestone 4.
18.1. AI Use - IMPORTANT#
Include an AI Use Log with the Milestone 3 design memo and every team deliverable after it. Review the AI Usage Policy from Milestone 1 before you use any AI tool on project work.
18.2. Tasks#
Task |
Who |
Deliverable |
|---|---|---|
Individual |
Gradescope activity |
|
Team |
One memo (PDF) with flowchart |
|
Team |
First-draft controller that keeps the crop alive |
18.3. Your Report This Milestone (TP3)#
In your Technical Report, draft section VI.
Prototyping, Testing and Weighted Decision Matrix and VII. Iteration #1. Leave
VI.c Test Results for the Chosen Design blank in TP3; it is completed and graded in
TP4, after your team completes the
First Draft and Iteration #1 assignment.
Your team will create a weighted decision matrix when drafting your Design Memo. Complete this assignment before writing section VI.d Weighted Decision Matrix (WDM). Submit the WDM Excel spreadsheet (M3_WDM_team_#.xlsx) with your report PDF for TP3.
Additionally, narrow IV. Idea Generation to your finalists and revise III.b Design Criteria and Constraints with the evidence you have gathered.
Choose APA or MLA and use that style consistently for in-text citations and the corresponding entries in Section X. References.
Save your report as a PDF named TP3_design_project_report_team_#.pdf and submit it
with the WDM spreadsheet as a group to 18.3 TP3: Design Project Report - Milestone 3 (Team) in Gradescope. Submit before the deadline listed on the
Course Schedule.
Learning Objectives
- IF01:
Idea Generation - Generate a wide range of solution ideas, including non-obvious or combined approaches.
- IF02:
Use Ideation Strategies - Use and document multiple ideation strategies to generate ideas.
- IF03:
Prototyping - Generate testable prototypes representing potential solutions.
- EB01:
Testing and Comparison - Test prototypes and analyze results to compare alternative solutions.
- EB04:
Metrics and Weighting - Justify evaluation metrics and weighting based on stakeholder priorities.
- EB05:
Iterative Improvement - Present findings from iterative testing or optimization efforts.
- EB06:
Reasoned Decision Explanation - Clearly articulate reasoning when evaluating alternatives or making decisions.
- PR06:
Translate Program Descriptions - Translate written descriptions or flowcharts into working code.
- PR08:
Debugging - Debug and refine code so that it achieves its objective without dynamic or semantic errors.
- PS05:
Problem Revision - Revise the problem statement based on new evidence or insights.
- EC02:
Recognize Limits, Trade-offs, and Confidence - Recognize limitations, trade-offs, and uncertainty in engineering work and communicate appropriate levels of confidence in conclusions.
- UC02:
Schematic Representation of Systems - Describe engineering systems or processes using schematic diagrams that represent inputs, outputs, and accumulations.
- UC04:
Types of Engineering Models - Differentiate between common types of models used in engineering and explain their purposes and limitations.
- PC01:
Written Communication Standards - Use professional tone, clear sentence structure, and correct spelling and grammar in all written work.
- PC03:
Captioning Visuals - Include professional captions for all figures, tables, and plots that describe what is shown and why it is relevant.
- PC05:
Meeting Assignment Expectations - Fully complete all parts of each assignment according to provided instructions.
- TM02:
Document Contributions - Provide clear evidence of individual contributions to the team’s work, including technical, written, or supportive tasks.
- EB03:
Data-Supported Justification - Justify decisions or comparisons using explicit reference to data.
- DV01:
Table and Plot Formatting - Prepare tables and plots for technical presentation with proper formatting. Include descriptive titles, axis labels with units, appropriately scaled axes, and visible legends.
- DV03:
Graphical Comparison of Data - Select, interpret, and justify appropriate graphical representations of data based on data type and structure. Use plots to compare distributions and identify patterns.
- PA02:
Identify Limitations in Process - Identify limitations, challenges, or inefficiencies in the problem-solving or design approach.
- PA03:
Plan for Process Improvement - Identify concrete behaviors or strategies to improve future problem-solving or design efforts.